A Bibliometric Analysis of the Current Trends in Collaboration Skills in the Learning Process
Abstract
This study aims to analyze research trends related to collaboration skills in the learning process from 2019 to 2023 through bibliometric analysis with the Scopus database. Based on the criteria, 740 articles from 3176 documents were obtained. The articles have been analyzed from Scopus-indexed international journals. The selected references were supervised utilizing Mendeley, a reference management software. Once it was processed, this study classified and visualized the data using VOSviewer software. The results indicate that research on collaboration skills in the learning process is gradually increasing every year. The United States accounts for the most research globally, followed by Indonesia in fourth place. Four clusters were found while visualizing the research trend of collaboration skills in the learning process from 2019 to 2023. The results of this study offer guidance to future researchers and support them in their research of global trends in the study of collaboration skills in the learning process. Overall, this review serves as a good foundation for subsequent research concerning collaboration skills in the learning process.
Keywords: bibliometric analysis, collaboration skills, learning proses
References
[1] Andris V. Aplikasi mendeley berbasis 4c (critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, dan communication) dalam menulis karya ilmiah bagi guru di pokja mgmp ipa jakarta barat. J Pendidik Indones [Internet]. 2023;4(9):1016–27. Available from: https://japendi.publikasiindonesia.id/index.php/japendi/article/view/2225
[2] Undari M, Darmansyah, Desyandri. Pengaruh Penerapan Model Pjbl (Project-Based Learning) Terhadap Keterampilan Abad 21. J Tunas Bangsa. 2023;10(1):25–33.
[3] Suryana E, Aprina MP, Harto K. Teori Konstruktivistik dan Implikasinya dalam Pembelajaran. JIIP - J Ilm Ilmu Pendidik. 2022;5(7):2070–80.
[4] Ihwanto N, Warni H, Mashud. Upaya Meningkatkan Keterampilan Kolaborasi dan Hasil Belajar Siswa dengan Menggunakan Model Teams Games Tournament Efforts to improve collaboration Skills and Student Learning Outcomes. J Maenpo J Pendidik Jasm Kesehat dan Rekreasi. 2022;12(2):191–205.
[5] Yusliani E, Burhan HL, Nafsih NZ. Analisis Integrasi Keterampilan Abad Ke-21 Dalam Sajian Buku Teks Fisika SMA Kelas XII Semester 1. J Eksakta Pendidik. 2019;3(2):184– 91.
[6] Ulhusna M, Diana Putri S, Zakirman. Permainan Ludo untuk Meningkatkan Keterampilan Kolaborasi Siswa dalam Pembelajaran Matematika. Int J Elem Educ. 2020;4(2):130–7.
[7] Septikasari R, Frasandy RN. Keterampilan 4c abad 21 dalam pembelajaran pendidikan dasar. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2018;8(2):107–16.
[8] Wardani DAW. Problem based learning: membuka peluang kolaborasi dan pengembangan skill siswa. J Penelit dan Penjaminan Mutu. 2023;4(1):1–17.
[9] Robbia AZ, Fuadi H. Pengembangan Keterampilan Multimedia Interaktif Pembelajaran IPA Untuk Meningkatkan Literasi Sains Peserta Didik di Abad 21. J Ilm Profesi Pendidik. 2020;5(2):117–23.
[10] Zubaidah S. Self Regulated Learning: Pembelajaran dan Tantangan pada Era Revolusi Industri 4.0. In: Prosiding SNPBS (Seminar Nasional Pendidikan Biologi dan Saintek) [Internet]. Surakarta: Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta; 2020. p. 1–19. Available from: https://proceedings.ums.ac.id/index.php/snpbs/article/view/706
[11] Kurniawan R, Hendracipta N, Pribadi RA. Penerapan Metode Tutor Sebaya Dalam Pembelajaran Matematika. J Ilm Manaj [Internet]. 2023;14(1):169. Available from: https://doi.org/10.32670/coopetition.v14i1.3156
[12] Arnyana IBP. Pembelajaran untuk meningkatkan kompetensi 4c (communication, collaboration, critical thinking dancreative thinking) untuk menyongsong era abad 21. In: Prosiding : Konferensi Nasional Matematika dan IPA Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi [Internet]. Jawa Timur: Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi; 2019. Available from: https://ejournal.unibabwi.ac.id/index.php/knmipa/article/view/829
[13] Umar F, Misbah M, Ekawati FF, Hanief YN. A bibliometric analysis of adaptive physical education. J Phys Educ Sport. 2022;22(12):2996–3002.
[14] Misbah M, Hamidah I, Sriyati S, Samsudin A. A bibliometric analysis: Research trend of critical thinking in science education. J Eng Sci Technol. 2022;17:118–26.
[15] Aditya UB, Wahyudi W. Implementasi Teams Games Tournament Untuk Meningkatkan Keterampilan Kolaborasi Siswa Kelas Sekolah Dasar. Sch J Pendidik dan Kebud. 2024;14(01):88–97.
[16] Nurhayati I, Pramono KSE, Farida A. Keterampilan 4C (Critical Thinking, Creativity, Communication and Collaboration) dalam Pembelajaran IPS untuk Menjawab Tantangan Abad 21. J Basicedu [Internet]. 2024;8(1):44–53.
[17] Gilroy D, Young G. Adding value to learning and development through CILIP accreditation: The NHS knowledge for healthcare learning academy. Health Info Libr J. 2023;40(2):223–7.
[18] Li K, Griffin MA, Barker T, Prickett Z, Hodkiewicz MR, Kozman J, et al. Embedding data science innovations in organizations: A new workflow approach. Data-Centric Eng. 2023;4(4).
[19] Kumpunen S, Bridgwood B, Irving G, Amuthalingam T, Matthews J, Pettigrew LM. Workplace-based knowledge exchange programmes between academics, policymakers and providers in the health and social care sector: A scoping review and mapping exercise. Humanit Soc Sci Commun. 2023;10(1):1–21.
[20] Heatly MC, Nichols-Hadeed C, Stiles AA, Alpert-Gillis L. Implementation of a school mental health learning collaborative model to support cross-sector collaboration. School Ment Health [Internet]. 2023;15(2):384–401.
[21] Durand H, Balhasan S. An example of using collaborative online international learning for petroleum and chemical engineering undergraduate courses. Int Rev Res Open Distance Learn. 2023;24(3):225–33.
[22] Barber S, Otis M, Greenfield G, Razzaq N, Solanki D, Norton J, et al. Improving multidisciplinary team working to support integrated care for people with frailty amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. Int J Integr Care. 2023;23(1):1–13.
[23] Carrera P, Boshoff K, Wiles L, Phillips R, Gibbs D, Porter L. Understanding parents’ experiences with mainstream schooling for their children with autism spectrum disorder: A meta-analysis. Am J Occup Ther. 2023;77(4):1–12.
[24] Tullo E, Wakeling L, Pearse R, Kheng Khoo T, Teodorczuk A. Lost in translation: How can education about dementia be effectively integrated into medical school contexts? A realist synthesis. BMJ Open. 2023;13(11).
[25] Ismail H, Edi. Student need analysis of problem-based learning model with blended learning in EFL academic reading. Int J English Lang Lit Stud. 2023;12(1):1–16.
[26] Yang Y, Wang M, Sang WL, Zhang YY, Liu W, Wu SF. Student-driven coursebased undergraduate research experience (CUREs) projects in identifying vaginal microorganism species communities to promote scientific literacy skills. Front Public Heal. 2022;10(April).
[27] Biswas NK, Stanley TA, Kirschbaum DB, Amatya PM, Meechaiya C, Poortinga A, et al. A dynamic landslide hazard monitoring framework for the Lower Mekong Region. Front Earth Sci. 2022;10(November):1–15.
[28] Kaewurai W, Yuh AH, Khongcharoen P. A development of a schools’ network for co-teacher development to enhance teachers’ professional competencies for appropriate instruction in situations of pandemic spread. Kasetsart J Soc Sci. 2023;44(3):885–94.
[29] Hairi F, Mohamad SNM, Saad S, Ahmad I. Determining Heutagogy design elements for online learning model using Fuzzy Delphi methods. J Theor Appl Inf Technol [Internet]. 2023;15(15):6156–64.
[30] Gummesson C, Alm S, Cederborg A, Ekstedt M, Hellman J, Hjelmqvist H, et al. Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) for undergraduate medical education – development and exploration of social validity. BMC Med Educ. 2023;23(1):1–11.
[31] Hess KY, Rihtman T. Moving from theory to practice in occupational therapy education for planetary health: A theoretical view. Aust Occup Ther J. 2023;70(4):460–70.
[32] Gamaliia K, Turchak-Lazurenko L, Lavrenyuk O, Penchuk O, Lytvynenko N. Synergy of design, culture, and innovation in pedagogy: New horizons for education. Res J Adv Humanit [Internet]. 2023;4(2):11–9. Available from:
[33] Aerila JA, Rönkkö ML, Stenius T. Humour-themed holistic learning processes in a Finnish primary school. Eur J Humour Res. 2023;11(4):75–92.
[34] Lo Presti V. The social impact of distance learning in Roman schools: “Success,” social innovation, teaching practices. Front Sociol. 2023;8.
[35] Connolly C, Logue PA, Calderon A. Teaching about curriculum and assessment through inquiry and problem-based learning methodologies: an initial teacher education cross-institutional study. Irish Educ Stud. 2023;42(3):443–60.
[36] Asotska-Wierzba Y. Synchronous computer-supported collaborative writing of a proposal during the pandemic. Neofilolog. 2021;(2):197–216.
[37] Charrette AL, Sullivan KM, Kucharski-Howard J, Seed S, Lorenz L. Physical therapy and pharmacy interprofessional education in the context of a university pro bono physical therapy setting. J Interprof Care [Internet]. 2020;34(3):315–23.
[38] Haddock LM, Upton M, Polomano RC, Myers JS, Nandiwada DR, Miller RK. Interprofessional 30-day readmission review novel curriculum. J Interprof Care [Internet]. 2021;35(1):153–6. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1080/13561820.2020.1711719
[39] Brewer ML, Flavell HL. Teamwork, collaboration and networking: self-reported behavioural change following pre-licensure interprofessional clinical learning. J Interprof Care. 2020;34(2):184–92.
[40] Worum H, Lillekroken D, Roaldsen KS, Ahlsen B, Bergland A. Reflections of older people about their experience of fall prevention exercise in the communitya qualitative study exploring evidence-based practice. BMC Public Health. 2020;20(1):1–16.
[41] Kumar M, Truss A, Bauman J, Cooper AG. Experiential learning through program evaluation: Assessing external barriers to Bridgehaven attendance. J Prev Interv Community [Internet]. 2023;51(2):141–54.
[42] Falcone F, Alejos AV, Cenoz JG, Lopez-Martin A. Implementation of higher education and life long learning curricula based on university-industry synergic approach. Int J Eng Educ. 2019;35(6):1568–83.