Is Marriage Age Restriction Un-Islamic? (Comparative Study of Indonesia and Pakistan with Gender Perspective)
Abstract
Like a recent epidemic, child marriages are prevalent not only in Indonesia but also in Pakistan. Even though both countries have ratified CEDAW and have laws and regulations governing the age of marriage. However, the BPS data (2020-2022) shows that the number of underage marriages are still high in several regions, with up to 34,000 applicants for marriage dispensation in 2022 in Indonesia. Likewise, the phenomenon also occurs in Pakistan, as its Human Rights Commission in Lahore in 2022 stated that at least 99 cases of child marriage were reported to them. Why is it difficult for the two countries to suppress the number of child marriages? Is it because the age limit for marriage is not Islamic? And what are the countermeasures from a gender perspective? Using the comparative method of laws in Indonesia and Pakistan from secondary sources, it can be concluded that these two countries are predominantly Muslim. Although the legal systems used in both countries are plural, where the law of marriage is still strong in Islamic law, and regarding the application of the marriage age, both the countries have attempted to have an age limit. Even though in the Islamic conception there is no age limit for marriage and only aqil and baliq are required, which according to most scholars stipulate that the age of aqil baliq is not the same as one another. This shows that the age limit for marriage is very Islamic because it is for the benefit of the child. Apart from that social culture poverty and promiscuity also contributed to the increase in the number of underage marriages. Therefore, it is necessary to fulfill the legal awareness of all parties, especially law enforcement in overcoming the negative impact on children’s rights (especially girls).
Keywords: underage marriage, Islamic concept, children’s rights, gender perspective, comparative law
References
[1] UNICEF Indonesia BPS, PUSKAPA UI, & Ministry of National Development Planning/Bappenas, 2020. Child marriage fact sheet. https://unicef.org/indonesia/id/report/perkawinananak-di-indonesia
[2] Ministry of Women’s Empowerment and Child Protection of the Republic of Indonesia (Kementerian PPA). 16 February 2021. Threatening the future, Let’s Prevent Child Marriage, Press Release Number: B- 027/SETMEN/ HM.02.04/02/2021. https://www.kemenpppa.go.id/index.php/page/read/29/3053/mengancam-masadepan- mari-prevent-perkawinan-ana
[3] Suara.com. October 21 2020. Early marriage cases increase during the pandemic period. https://yoursay.voice.com/news/2020/10/21/110151/casespernikahandini- meningkat- during-pandemi.
[4] United Nations. (UN) Sustainable Development Goalshttps://sdgs.bappenas.go.idjo United Nations (UN), 2015. Sustainable Development Goals. (n.d.). Goals 5: Achieve Gender Equality and Empower All Women and Girls. http://sustainabledevelopment. un.org/sdg5johttps://www.unwomen.org/en/news/in-focus/women-and-the-sdgs
[5] “VOA NEWS. The value of girls: Child marriage around the world, Pakistan”. accessed from https://projects.voanews.com/child-marriage/indonesian/region/pakistan.html
[6] “Pakistan: Child marriage around the world. Girls Not Brides”. 2018. Accessed from https://www.girlsnotbrides.org/child-marriage/pakistan/
[7] “UNICEF: Child Marriage Database”. 2019. Accessed from https://data.unicef.org/wpcontent/ uploads/2017/11/Child-marriage-database_Oct-2019.xlsx
[8] Djoni Sumardi Gozali, Pengantar Perbandingan Sistem Hukum, Penerbit Nusa Media, Bandung 2018 ; Bab I, h.3.
[9] The Gender Study Study Program School of Strategic and Global Studies University of Indonesia and KPPPA with the title “Child marriage in the perspective of Islam, Catholicism, Protestantism, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Hindu Kaharingan, 2016
[10] Sonny Dewi Judiasih Dkk. Sustainable development goals and elimination of children’s marriage practice. Indonesia “ jurnal Notariil : Program Pascasarjana Universitas Warmadewa. Program Studi Magister Kenotariatan; 2019.
[11] Siti Yuli Astuty, Journal article // Welfare State;
[12] Djamilah RK. The impact of child marriage in Indonesia. J Youth Stud. 2014 May;3(1):.
[13] Jamila R. Phenomena of child marriage in Sumenep Madura. Harkat Journal: Gender Communication Media. 2019;15(1):34–9.
[14] Subulah U, Jannah F. Early marriage and its implications for family life in Madurese Society (Legal and Gender Perspective). Journal of Gender Equality and Justice. 2012;VII(1).
[15] Nurhidayatuloh N, Marlina L. Underage marriage from a human rights perspectivecase study in Bulungihit Village, Labuhan Batu, North Sumatra. Al-Mawarid Journal of Islamic Law. 2011;11(2):26066.
[16] Sulaiman. “Tradition domination in underage marriage”. Journal Analysis. 2012;19(1).
[17] Mutamah AL, Latifiani D, Arifin R. Early marriage in Indonesia: Factors and the role of the government (Perspective of law enforcement and protection for children). Widya Yuridika: Journal of Law. 2019;2(1):1–12.
[18] Kartikawati R. Impact of child marriage in Indonesia. J Youth Stud. 2015.
[19] Atikah Rahmi. Child-age marriage: Legal implications and efforts to prevent its perspective human rights and Islamic Law. Journal Sanksi Home. 2022;1(1).
[20] Fadlyana E, Larasty S. Early marriage and its problems. Sari Pediatrics. 2016;11(2):136– 41.
[21] Musfiroh MR. Early marriage and child protection efforts in Indonesia. De Jure: Journal of Law and Sharia. 2016;8(2):64–73.
[22] Syarifuddin A. Islamic Marriage Law in Indonesia: Between Fiqh Munakahat and Marriage Law, ( Jakarta: Kencana, 2006), h. 39.
[23] Compilation of Islamic Law, Article 2 and Article 3. Third edition, June 2006, Widyatama Library. Jakarta.
[23] Made AR. Underage marriage from a traditional law viewpoint. Journal of Lex Privatium. 2018 Oct;VI(8):79.
[24] Noor Z. Child marriage and minimum marriage age in Islamic Family Law. Journal of Syari’ah. 2013;21(2):166.
[25] Mohammad Daud Ali. Islamic law: An introduction to the science of law and the rule of Islamic law in Indonesia. Jakarta: PT Raja Grafindo Persada; 2005.