Covid-19 and Waste Management Law: Do Hard and Soft Laws Complement Each Other?
Abstract
The Covid-19 pandemic has led to various health, economic, and environmental problems. Waste management is one of the environmental problems that have emerged during this pandemic. Countries worldwide are trying to overcome the increase in the quantity and type of waste during the pandemic, such as disposable masks, face shields, and gloves, whether from households, commercial areas, or quarantine homes. Then there is also much medical waste sourced from health service places and places where people do swab testing and Covid-19 vaccinations. Moreover, there are other problems like increasing plastic waste from food consumption in the household during work and school activities from home. These waste problems add to the complexity of waste management, especially in developing countries which still needs improvement in their law and policy, technology, capacity, and legal awareness of the community in waste management. An interesting legal phenomenon during the Covid-19 pandemic is the widespread use of soft laws in the form of protocols, circulars, instructions, and appeals. This paper aims to study various forms of soft law used by the Government of Indonesia to manage Covid waste and analyze their compliance with national laws. This paper consists of two main parts: describing the trends in the use of soft law in waste management during the Covid-19 pandemic, and an analysis of the relationship between “hard law” and “soft law” in handling COVID-19 waste.
Keywords: Covid-19, environmental impact, soft law, waste management
References
[1] Agamuthu P, Barasarathi J. Clinical waste management under COVID-19 scenario in Malaysia. Waste Management & Research. 2021 Jun;39(1):18–26.
[2] Apriyani MN, Purwanto AM. Regulations for waste management of disposable mask during the Covid-19 pandemic. Untag Law Review. 2021 Nov;5(2):22–30.
[3] Arumugam V, Abdullah I, Yusoff IS, Abdullah NL, Tahir RM, Nasir AM, et al. The impact of COVID-19 on solid waste generation in the perspectives of socioeconomic and people’s behavior: A case study in Serdang, Malaysia. Sustainability. 2021;13:13045.
[4] Asian Development Bank-ADB. Managing infectious medical waste during the COVID-19 Pandemic. ADB; 2020.
[5] Aperio Bella F, Lauri C, Capra G. The role of COVID-19 Soft Law Measures in Italy: Much ado about nothing? European Journal of Risk Regulation. 2021 Mar;12(1):93– 110.
[6] Boschetti B, Poly MD. A comparative study on Soft Law: Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic. Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies. 2021;23:20–53.
[7] Cheng X. Soft Law in the prevention and control of the COVID-19 pandemic in China: Between Legality Concerns and Limited Participatory Possibilities. European Journal of Risk Regulation. 2021 Mar;12(1):7–25.
[8] Daly S. The Rule of (Soft) Law. King’s Law Journal. 2021;32(1):3–13.
[9] Das AK, Islam MN, Billah MM, Sarker A. COVID-19 pandemic and healthcare solid waste management strategy - A mini-review. Science of the Total Environment. 2021 Jul;778:146220.
[10] Utrilla Fernández-Bermejo D. Soft Law Governance in times of coronavirus in Spain. European Journal of Risk Regulation. 2021 Mar;12(1):111–126
[11] Friedman LM. The legal system: A social science perspective. Russell Sage; 1975..
[12] Hadjon PM, Martosoewignjo RS, Basah S, Manan B, Marzuki HM, ten Berge JB, et al. Introduction to Indonesian Administrative Law. 9th ed. Gadjah Mada University Press; 2005.
[13] Ministry of Environment and Forestry-MOEF. (n.d.). SIPSN. SIPSN - National Waste Management Information System. Retrieved April 11, 2022, from https://sipsn.menlhk.go.id/sipsn/public/data/timbulan
[14] Kojima M, Iwasaki F, Johannes HP, Edita EP. (2020, July). Strengthening waste management policies to mitigate the COVID-19 Pandemic. In Eria Policy Brief (Issue 2020-05). Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia.
[15] Listiningrum P, Firdaus RS, Annamalia Q, Mayarana A. Optimization of regulations, facilities, and public awareness of infectious waste handling during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Legal Dedication. 2021 Nov;1(3):202–219.
[16] Muhjad MH, Razy F, Hadin AF. The problematics of management personal protection equipment waste related to Covid-19 in Indonesia. Sriwijaya Law Review. 2021 Jul;5(2):300–308.
[17] Nelken D. Using the concept of legal culture. Australian Journal of Legal Philosophy. 2014;29:1–26.
[18] Nguyen TD, Kawai K, Nakakubo T. Estimation of COVID-19 waste generation and composition in Vietnam for pandemic management. Waste Management and Research. 2021 Nov;39(11):1356–1364.
[19] Nugraha C. Review of infectious medical waste management policy for handling corona virus disease 2019 (Covid-19). Journal for Healthy Society-Jukmas. 2020 Oct;4(2):216–229.
[20] Panjaitan VE. (2021, September). Comparison of Covid-19 medical waste management policies in Indonesia and Malaysia. Tata A Million. 2020 Dec;7(2): 1-23.
[21] Purwanto NR, Amin SA, Mardiyah A, Wahyuningtyas YR. Covid-19 medical waste management arrangements. Yustika Journal. 2020 Dec;23(2):67–76.
[22] Sangkham S. Face mask and medical waste disposal during the novel COVID- 19 pandemic in Asia. Case Studies in Chemical and Environmental Engineering. 2020;2:1–9.
[23] Soekanto S. (1977). Legal awareness and legal compliance. Law and Development. 7(6): 75
[24] UNEP. (2020). Policy and legislation linked to COVID-19 and pandemics. In Covid-19 Waste Management Factsheet.
[25] ‘United Nations Environment Programme-UNEP, International Environmental Technology Center (IETC), & IGES Center Collaborating with UNEP on Environmental Technologies (CCET). Waste Management during the COVID-19 Pandemic from Response to Recovery. UNEP. 2020.
[26] Wardani RA, Azizah R. Management of solid medical waste on one of the COVID- 19 referral hospitals in Surabaya, East Java. Journal of Environmental Health. 2020 Sep;12(1):38–44.
[27] Wijaya H, Haryanto I. (2021, November). Law enforcement against medical waste management negligence Covid-19 sample examination by start-up companies. Budapest International Research and Critics Institute-Journal (BIRCI-Journal). 2021 Nov;4(4):13630-13640.
[28] Yasin M. (2020, March). From protocols to advisories: Get to know the various types of Beleidsregel related to Covid-19. Hukumonline. 2020 Mar. Retrieved February 24, 2022. https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/dari-protokol-hingga-imbauan–kenalianeka- jenis-ibeleidsregel-i-terkait-covid-19-lt5e8305ba0bee6
[29] Yolarita E, Kusuma DW. Hospital medical B3 waste management in West Sumatra during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Health Ecology. 2020 Dec;19(3):148–60.