Alternatives to Long Distance Resettlement for Urban Informal Settlements Affected By Disaster and Climate Change
Abstract
Planned or managed resettlement is increasingly being seen as a logical and legitimate disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation strategy for urban informal settlements in many developing country cities. Our understanding of the 50+ year history of “Development-induced Displacement” (i.e. resettlement for resource extraction or development project purposes) strongly suggests that resettlement, particularly long distance resettlement, often triggers significant, negative impacts for resettled communities. We now understand that long distance resettlement should be seen as an option of last resort. Under most climate change scenarios, informal settlements in coastal, or riverside locations are expected to be impacted negatively by climatic change, and thus the question of whether or not to resettle (despite the negatives associated with this) still arises. This paper will present several emerging and innovative alternatives to long distance resettlement, including the so-called “vertical resettlement”, amphibious and floating housing, “near-site” resettlement, and in-situ climate change adaptation/upgrading. These alternatives collectively allow for a local “re-imagining of informal settlements” rather than simply “resettlement”. The research methods used in this paper include a review of secondary data (n=20), and limited primary field research involving resettlement site observation and several key informant interviews (n=2).
Keywords: resettlement, climate change, near-site resettlement, floating houses, amphibious houses, in-situ upgrading, vertical resettlement
References
[1] Correa, E., Ramirez, F. and Sanahuja, H. (2011). Populations at Risk of Disaster A Resettlement Guide. The World Bank: Washington.
[2] Doberstein, B. and Stager, H. (2013). Towards guidelines for post-disaster vulnerability reduction in informal settlements. Disasters. 37 (1): 28-47.
[3] Dovey, K. (2015). Sustainable Informal Settlements? International conference green architecture for sustainable living and environment. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences. 179: 5-13
[4] Elkin, R.S., and Keenan, J.M. (2018). Retreat or Rebuild: Exploring Geographic Retreat in Humanitarian Practices in Coastal Communities. In W. Leal Filho (ed.), Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Strategies for Coastal Communities. pp.149-165.
[5] English, E., Klink, N., and Turner, S. (2016). Thriving with water: developments in amphibious architecture in North America. In proceedings, FLOODrisk 2016 - 3rd European Conference on Flood Risk Management. 17th - 21st October 2016, Lyon, France.
[6] Gill, M., and Bhide, A. (2012). Densification through vertical resettlement as a tool for sustainable. Presented at the Sixth Urban Research and Knowledge Symposium, October 2012, Barcelona, Spain, http://siteresources.worldbank.org/ INTURBANDEVELOPMENT/Resources/336387-1369969101352/Gill-et-al.pdf
[7] Hanson, S., Nicholls, R., Ranger, N., Hallegatte, S., Corfee-Morlot, J., Herweijer, C., and Chateau, J. (2011). A global ranking of port cities with high exposure to climate extremes. Climatic Change. 104 (1): 89-111.
[8] Hossain, M.Z., and Rahman, M.A.U. (2018). Pro-poor adaptation for the urban extreme poor in the context of climate change: A study on Dhaka City, Bangladesh. International Journal of Climate Change Strategies and Management. 10 (3): 389- 406
[9] Kellett, J., and Caravani, A. (2013). Financing disaster risk reduction: a 20 year story of international aid. Accessed on Sept. 1, 2018 at https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org. uk/files/odi-assets/publications-opinion-files/8574.pdf
[10] Key Informant #1. (2016). Senior NGO member, Solo/Surakarta. May 19, 2016.
[11] Key Informant #2. (2016). Junior NGO Staff member, Solo/Surakarta. May 19, 2016.
[12] Los Angeles Times (2014). The Week in Pictures: July 14-20, 2014. Accessed on Aug. 26, 2018 at http://framework.latimes.com/2014/07/18/the-week-in-pictures-189/#/18
[13] McCallin and Scherer (2015). Urban informal settlers displaced by disasters: challenges to housing responses. Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre: Geneva. Accessed on Aug. 23, 2018 at http://www.internal-displacement.org/sites/default/ files/publications/documents/201506-global-urban-informal-settlers.pdf
[14] Sattherthwaite, D., Archer, D., Colenbrander, S., Dodman, D., Hardoy, J., and Patel, S. (2018). Responding to climate change in cities and in their informal settlements and economies. Accessed on Aug. 28, 2018 at https://citiesipcc.org/wp-content/uploads/ 2018/03/Informality-background-paper-for-IPCC-Cities.pdf
[15] Smith, D. (2008). Favelas of Sao Paulo: Part 2, Guarapiranga. Accessed on Aug 31, 2018. http://affordablehousinginstitute.org/blogs/us/2008/06/favelas-of-sao-paulopart-2 guarapiranga.html
[16] Tadgell, A., Doberstein, B., and Mortsch, L. (2017a). Principles for climate-related resettlement of informal settlements in less-developed nations: A review of resettlement literature and institutional guidelines. Climate and Development. 10:2, 102-115.
[17] Tadgell, A., Mortsch, L., and Doberstein, B. (2017b). The feasibility of resettlement as a climate change adaptation strategy for informal settlements in Metro Manila, Philippines. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction. 22: 447-457.
[18] Taylor, J. (2015). A tale of two cities: comparing alternative approaches to reducing the vulnerability of riverbank communities in two Indonesian cities. Environment & Urbanization. Vol 27(2): 621–636.
[19] The Hindu (2016). HC denies relief to residents of hutments near tracks. Accessed on Aug 27, 2018 at https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/hc-denies-reliefto residents-of-hutments-near-tracks/article8291666.ece
[20] Vann, L. (2016). In Cambodian floating villages, a bold voice helps women boost income. Human Nature/Conservation International. Accessed on Sept 1, 2018 at https://blog.conservation.org/2016/03/in-cambodian-floating-villages-abold-voice-helps women-boost-income/
[21] Willaert, R. (2010). Manila-Smoky Mountain area. Accessed on Aug. 23, 2018 at https://www.flickr.com/photos/rietje/4662019637/in/photostream/
[22] World Bank. (2004). Involuntary resettlement: planning and implementation in development projects. Worldbank: Washington, D.C.