Manual Segmentation of 12 Layers of the Retina and Choroid through SD-OCT in Intermediate AMD: Repeatability and Reproducibility
Purpose: To evaluate the repeatability and reproducibility of the segmentation of 12 layers of the retina and the choroid, performed manually by SD-OCT, along the horizontal meridian at three different temporal moments, and to evaluate its concordance with the same measurements performed by two other operators in intermediate AMD.
Methods: A cross-sectional study of 40 eyes from 40 subjects with intermediate AMD was conducted. The segmentation was performed manually, using SD-OCT. The 169 measurements per eye were repeated at three time points to study the intra-operator variability. The same process was repeated a single time by two different trained operators for the inter-operator variability.
Results: Forty participants (28 women and 12 men) were enrolled in this study, with an average age of 76.4 ± 8.2 (range, 55–92 years). Overall, the maximum values of the various structures were found in the 3 mm of the macula. Intra-operator variability: the highest ICC values turned out to be discovered in thicker locations. Inter-operator variability: except correlation values of 0.826 (0.727; 0.898) obtained in the OPL (T2.5) and 0.634 (0.469; 0.771) obtained in the IPL (N2), all other correlation values were >0.92, in most cases approaching higher values like 0.98.
Conclusion: The measurements of several layers of the retina and the choroid achieved at 13 locations presented a good repeatability and reproducibility. Manual quantification is still an alternative for the weaknesses of automatic segmentation. Locations of greatest concordance should be those used for the clinical control and monitoring.
Data Accuracy, Diagnostic Imaging, Macular Degeneration
1. Ctori I, Huntjens B. Repeatability of foveal measurements using spectralis optical coherence tomography segmentation software. PLoS One 2015;10:e0129005.
2. Pierro L, Giatsidis SM, Mantovani E, Gagliardi M. Macular thickness interoperator and intraoperator reproducibility in healthy eyes using 7 optical coherence tomography instruments. Am J Ophthalmol 2010;150:199–204.
3. Curcio CA, Messinger JD, Sloan KR, Mitra A, McGwin G, Spaide RF. Human chorioretinal layer thicknesses measured in macula-wide, high-resolution histologic sections. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2011;52:3943– 3954.
4. Camacho P, Dutra-Medeiros M, Páris L. Ganglion cell complex in early and intermediate age-related macular degeneration: evidence by SD-OCT manual segmentation. Ophthalmologica 2017;238:31–43.
5. Liu X, Shen M, Huang S, Leng L, Zhu D, Lu F. Repeatability and reproducibility of eight macular intra-retinal layer thicknesses determined by an automated segmentation algorithm using two SD-OCT instruments. PLoS One 2014;9:e87996.
6. Camacho P, Dutra-Medeiros M, Cabral D, Silva R. Outer retina and choroidal thickness in intermediate age-related macular degeneration: reticular pseudodrusen findings. Ophthalmic Res 2018;59:212–220.
7. Oberwahrenbrock T, Weinhold M, Mikolajczak J, Zimmermann H, Paul F, Beckers I, et al. Reliability of intra-retinal layer thickness estimates. PLoS One 2015;10:e0137316.
8. Krebs I, Hagen S, Brannath W, Haas P, Womastek I, De Salvo G, et al. Repeatability and reproducibility of retinal thickness measurements by optical coherence tomography in age-related macular degeneration. Ophthalmology 2010;117:1577–1584.
9. Loduca AL, Zhang C, Zelkha R, Shahidi M. Thickness mapping of retinal layers by spectral-domain optical coherence tomography. Am J Ophthalmol 2010;150:849– 855. 10. Eriksson U, Alm A, Larsson E. Is quantitative spectraldomain superior to time-domain optical coherence tomography (OCT) in eyes with age-related macular degeneration? Acta Ophthalmol 2012;90:620–627.
11. Leung CK-S, Chan WM, Chong KKL, Chan KC, Yung W ho, Tsang MK, et al. Alignment artifacts in optical coherence tomography analyzed images. Ophthalmology 2007;114:263–270.
12. Rahman W, Chen FK, Yeoh J, Patel P, Tufail A, Da Cruz L. Repeatability of manual subfoveal choroidal thickness measurements in healthy subjects using the technique of enhanced depth imaging optical coherence tomography. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2011;52:2267–2271.
13. Mishra Z, Ganegoda A, Selicha J, Wang Z, Sadda SVR, Hu Z. Automated retinal layer segmentation using graphbased algorithm incorporating deep-learning-derived information. Sci Rep 2020;10:1–8.
14. Borkovkina S, Camino A, Janpongsri W, Sarunic M V, Jian Y. Real-time retinal layer segmentation of OCT volumes with GPU accelerated inferencing using a compressed, low-latency neural network. Biomed Opt Express 2020;11:3968.
15. Ehnes A, Wenner Y, Friedburg C, Preising MN, Bowl W, Sekundo W, et al. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) device independent intraretinal layer segmentation. Transl Vis Sci Technol 2014;3:1.
16. American Academy of Ophthalmology Retina/Vitreous Panel. Preferred practice pattern® guidelines. Age-related macular degeneration. San Francisco, CA: American Academy of Ophthalmology; 2015.
17. Sohn EH, Khanna A, Tucker BA, Abràmoff MD, Stone EM, Mullins RF. Structural and biochemical analyses of choroidal thickness in human donor eyes. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2014;55:1352–1360.
18. Staurenghi G, Sadda S, Chakravarthy U, Spaide RF. Proposed lexicon for anatomic landmarks in normal posterior segment spectral-domain optical coherence tomography: the IN.OCT consensus. Ophthalmology 2014;121:1572–1578.
19. Krebs I, Smretschnig E, Moussa S, Brannath W, Womastek I, Binder S. Quality and reproducibility of retinal thickness measurements in two spectral-domain optical coherence tomography machines. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2011;52:6925–6933.
20. Wood A, Binns A, Margrain T, Drexler W, Povaay B, Esmaeelpour M, et al. Retinal and choroidal thickness in early age-related macular degeneration. Am J Ophthalmology 2011;152:1030–1038.e2.
21. Wang X-G, Peng Q, Wu Q. Comparison of central macular thickness between two spectral-domain optical coherence tomography in elderly non-mydriatic eyes. Int J Ophthalmology 2012;5:354–359.
22. Parravano M, Oddone F, Boccassini B, Menchini F, Chiaravalloti A, Schiavone M, et al. Reproducibility of macular thickness measurements using cirrus SD-OCT in neovascular age-related macular degeneration. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010;51:4788–4791.
23. Ho J, Sull AC, Vuong LN, Chen Y, Liu J, Fujimoto JG, et al. Assessment of artifacts and reproducibility across spectral- and time-domain optical coherence tomography devices. Ophthalmology 2009;116:1960–1970.
24. Garcia-Martin E, Pinilla I, Idoipe M, Fuertes I, Pueyo V. Intra and interoperator reproducibility of retinal nerve fibre and macular thickness measurements using Cirrus Fourierdomain OCT. Acta Ophthalmol 2011;89:23–30.
25. Mansouri K, Medeiros FA, Tatham AJ, Marchase N, Weinreb RN. Evaluation of retinal and choroidal thickness by swept-source optical coherence tomography: repeatability and assessment of artifacts. Am J Ophthalmology 2014;157:1022–1032.e3.
26. Schuman SG, Koreishi AF, Farsiu S, Jung S, Izatt J a, Toth C a. Photoreceptor layer thinning over drusen in eyes with age-related macular degeneration imaged in vivo with spectral-domain optical coherence tomography. Ophthalmology 2009;116:488–496.e2.
27. Ooto S, Hangai M, Tomidokoro A, Saito H, Araie M, Otani T, et al. Effects of age, sex, and axial length on the threedimensional profile of normal macular layer structures. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2011;52:8769–8779.